The Myth of a Secular Australia
30 June 2020
Aussies are a laid-back bunch. That’s partly why we don’t like to talk religion or politics in polite company. When these topics come up at a dinner party, our impulse is to keep it light-hearted, or make a point of cutting down the tall poppies, whether priestly or political.
The story we tell ourselves is that as an immigrant society built by convicts and other misfits, Australia was born this way — born modern and more worldly than our British forebears.
Our convict mythology makes it easier for Aussie secularists to say “keep religion out of politics”. With such logic, public schools are guarded from religious education classes, and debates about abortion are hushed. The only problem is that this mythology is exactly that — a myth.
Stephen Chavura, who lectures in history at Campion College, has published and spoken extensively on this topic. He explains that while it’s true that Australia wasn’t founded as a “Christian nation”, we did proclaim ourselves as proudly British. And by definition, that meant Protestant.
It can be too easy, Chavura says, to take the convict experience and project it on to the rest of Australia. In fact, convicts were only arriving here until the 1850s. Both before and after this, there were vast numbers of free settlers arriving from England, Ireland, Scotland and other parts of Europe.
As an example of this, I grew up in Lobethal in the Adelaide Hills — one of many German settlements in South Australia founded in the 19th century. Lobethal was Martin Luther’s translation of the “valley of praise” mentioned in 2 Chronicles 20:26.
Like so many of Australia’s free settlers, my ancestors made it a priority to build a place of worship when they first arrived. Travel anywhere in Australia today — to country towns especially — and you will see churches, chapels and cathedrals that still stand as a testimony to Australia’s strong Christian roots.
In the lead up to our Federation in 1901, Australia’s Christian identity was rigorously discussed. And so it should have been: at that point, the percentage of Australians identifying as Christians was in the high 90s.
Thousands of Australians petitioned their federation delegates to make sure the phrase “humbly relying on the blessing of Almighty God” was kept in our Constitution’s preamble. Chavura suggests that, had the delegates ignored these pleas, everyday Australians may have voted against Federation itself — so strongly did they feel about the issue!
The other part of our Constitution that mentions religion is Section 116, which reads:
“The Commonwealth shall not make any law for establishing any religion, or for imposing any religious observance, or for prohibiting the free exercise of any religion, and no religious test shall be required as a qualification for any office or public trust under the Commonwealth.”
In recent decades, this section enshrining the separation of church and state has been used by secularists to argue for a “secular Australia” — a nation free of religion. But the intent of our Constitution’s drafters was in fact the opposite.
Australia’s founders weren’t trying to “keep religion out of politics”. That phrase would have made little sense in the 1800s, given how many of the delegates were animated by their Christian faith. What they sought to stop with Section 116 was the government’s overreach — financial or otherwise — into religious life.
A federation delegate from my own state of South Australia, Patrick Glynn, wrote that religion
“pervades all the relations of our civil life. It is felt in the forms of our courts of justice, in the language of our Statutes, in the oath that binds the sovereign to the observance of our liberties.”
When words like “secular” and “secularism” were used in early Australia, they didn’t describe a society free of religion. They described an Australia that all Christians — whether Protestant or Catholic — could agree on. “Non-denominational” or “non-sectarian” are perhaps the best way for us to understand our founders’ use of the word secular. This was important, given the significant minority of Irish Catholics that also called Australia home.
Stephen Chavura and Greg Melleuish provide other early evidence of Christianity’s strong influence on Australian culture. The first work of philosophy published in Australia was by Presbyterian minister Rev. Barzillai Quaife — one of many examples of the connection between philosophy and religion in Australia.
They write that
“clergymen played a significant role in the intellectual life of nineteenth-century NSW, as naturalists, political thinkers, and newspaper editors.”
Indeed Alfred Deakin, our second Prime Minister, declared that
“Without God and without immortality there can be no true or efficient morality from generation to generation, no task for the race, and no goal for it to attain.”
It was only from the 1960s that religious belief in Australia really started to decline — a phenomenon seen throughout the West. As late as the 1950s, only 10% of Australians claimed no religion.
So next time you hear someone say that Australia is a secular nation or that religion has no place in politics, remind them of our origins.
The Christian voice has every right to be heard in Australia. It is, after all, what gave us our religious freedom in the first place.[Photo by filmplusdigital on Unsplash]
28 March 2023
JP Sears — the well-known ‘freedom-fighter’ comedian — released a bombshell video last Friday (24 March 2023) titled, ‘I Changed My Mind About God — Here's Why’. This is big news. His brand, called ‘AwakenWithJP’, uses comedy to push back against today's fashionable and crazy. [...]
28 March 2023
Sometimes I read the newspaper and can’t work out whether to cry at the state of the world or laugh at how crazy things have become. Reading a column on the Let Women Speak movement at the weekend I mostly shook my head in disbelief. [...]
28 March 2023
The leftist Libs really are toast – long live the suspended Moira Deeming. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtZljvnweB4 Today was D-Day for Deeming – Moira Deeming, the beleaguered Liberal Party MP whose Christianity and conservatism are basically anathema to the lefty Libs – at least to the woke Lib party machine. [...]
28 March 2023
Australia’s Christian schools are under threat from “woke bigotry”, warns Senator Ralph Babet, who spoke up in their defence this week. In a passionate two-minute speech yesterday, UAP Senator for Victoria Ralph Babet offered a strong defence of Christian schools on the floor of the [...]
27 March 2023
Moria Deeming has been suspended from the Victorian Liberal Party for nine months. Her crime? For helping to organise a rally recently -- Let Women Speak! -- which was gatecrashed by neo-Nazis. Just to be clear, neither Deeming nor the other keynote speaker, Posey Parker, [...]
27 March 2023
A historic vote has just taken place (Wednesday night, 22 March 2023) to pass the Referendum (Machinery Provisions) Amendment Bill in both houses of the Federal Parliament. Opposition leader, Peter Dutton, gave Coalition support after securing some amendments in relation to the referendum on the [...]
27 March 2023
The topic of holiness is not one many Christians gravitate towards. Yet it is perhaps the key feature of the God we serve, and the attribute of God we most need to understand and aim for. And millions of words have been written on this [...]
Leave A Comment