Alex Antic

Senator Alex Antic Asked ‘What is a Woman?’ and the Department of Health Couldn’t Answer

7 April 2022

3.1 MINS

With one simple question, Senator Alex Antic this week revealed just how real the ‘slippery slope’ is. Five years ago we undefined marriage. Now Australia’s top medical minds can’t define a woman.

Can Australia’s Department of Health define what a woman is? This was the burning question that Liberal Senator for South Australia Alex Antic took to Senate estimates in Canberra this week.

The response given by the department’s head revealed just how far Australia has drifted from reality since the undefinition of marriage took place in 2017.

“I can’t seem to get a bureaucrat in this building to define what is a woman,” Senator Antic explained to his followers on social media soon after the exchange. “Today, I took it right to the top, straight to the Department of Health, and [received] one of the most extraordinary responses I’ve seen to date.”

Defining a Woman: ’Pretty Basic Stuff’

In a short one-minute video that has had over 150,000 views on Twitter since Wednesday, Senator Antic asks a panel of five of Australia’s top medical experts:

I’m going to finish up … with a very simple question for the department, and that is one which has troubled me for a great deal of time with the bureaucracy here. Can someone please provide me with a definition of what a woman is?

After a period of silence and blank stares, Antic probes further. “Department of Health,” he says incredulously. “Definition of a man. Definition of a woman. Anyone?”

“It’s pretty basic,” someone off camera can be heard saying. “Basic stuff,” Antic adds.

Professor Brendan Murphy, the Secretary of the Department of Health, begins moving uncomfortably in his chair, realising that he is the most senior figure in the room.

“There, look, I think there are a variety of definitions, and I think… Perhaps to give a more fulsome answer we should take that on notice,” he tells the Senator.

Antic is taken aback, asking, “You’re going to take on notice the question of what a woman is?”

“No, well there are a variety of… it’s a very, it’s a very, ah… it’s a very contested space at the moment Senator,” Professor Murphy continues. “There are definitions in terms of how people identify themselves so we’re happy to provide our working definition on that.”

Antic’s response couldn’t have been more appropriate. “I’ve only been here two years,” he remarks. “That’s the best thing I’ve seen thus far. Thank you so much.”

The Slippery Slope is Real

For thousands of years and until very recently, it was universally understood that a woman is an adult human female. The definition of “female” was also set in stone: the sex that can give birth to young or produce eggs.

These definitions were present across cultures, but in the West they were grounded in Scripture. The Bible sheds immense light on the dignity, value and calling of men and women. The foundational text is Genesis 1:27, which declares, “God created mankind in his own image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them.”

Bible-believing Christians and other conservatives warned that by introducing same-sex “marriage”, Western nations would de-gender marriage and lay the groundwork for the abolition of gender altogether.

Within just years, this “slippery slope argument”, once mocked by progressives, turns out to have been entirely accurate. Gender is now widely seen as a mere social construct, not grounded in objectivity.

Unmoored from a biblical understanding of reality, the West is losing its moral and intellectual compass.

Westerners are Waking Up to Woke Marxism 

The atheist philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) welcomed the “death of God”. He recognised that if the West abandoned Christian belief, it would be like “unchaining the earth from its sun”. Nietzsche conceded that the effects of this would only be seen in time.

Nietzsche’s words have likewise proven eerily prophetic.

To be clear, Professor Murphy and probably every other bureaucrat in the room knows what a woman is and could easily define the word. But knowingly or otherwise, they have been taken captive and effectively silenced by Queer Theory, a branch of woke Marxism that seeks to overthrow the “oppressive” “heteronormative” society that has always existed in the West.

The sort of “utopia” that woke Marxism hopes to introduce is still unclear — even to the most committed woke Marxists. But the fruit of it which we have seen so far couldn’t be more rotten.

Fortunately, God is gracious and he is using the rotten fruit of wokeness to wake Westerners up and call us back to himself.

The sanctity of gender couldn’t be more important. It is an eminently worthy hill for Christians to die on — not for our own sake but for the flourishing of women, men, children, and whole societies.


We need your help. The continued existence of the Daily Declaration depends on the generosity of readers like you. Donate now. The Daily Declaration is committed to keeping our site free of advertising so we can stay independent and continue to stand for the truth.

Fake news and big-tech censorship make the work of the Canberra Declaration and our Christian news site the Daily Declaration more important than ever. Take a stand for family, faith, freedom, life, and truth. Support us as we shine a light in the darkness. Donate today.



  1. saraya 8 April 2022 at 6:37 pm - Reply

    Impressed with senators question,baffled at the stupidity of those who controlled the voluntary and posed lockdowns poison darts in people’s arms with informed consent! …wake up people.

  2. Rick 10 April 2022 at 10:48 pm - Reply

    We have to get rid of these dimwits. If he/it/she as federal health minister cannot explain what a woman is in basic terms (DNA), perhaps we can aquire a male chimpanzee to replace him/it. It appears that a chimpanzee (male) knows exactly what a chimp of the OPPOSITE SEX is otherwise there would be no chimps left. Best part: They would work for peanuts.
    Sack them all!

  3. Paul 25 April 2022 at 9:27 pm - Reply

    What a 24 carat moron heading up the Dept of Health… does this fool take stupid pills or is he a natural… next question to him should be… do you have a penis… what gender are you dope?

Leave A Comment

Recent Articles

  • 17 August 2022

    0.6 MINS

    The Restoring Territory Rights Bill, which plans to overturn the 25-year-old ban on euthanasia legislation in the Northern Territory and ACT, was passed in the House of Representatives on Wednesday 3 August, 99 votes to 37. The private member's bill was briefly debated after being [...]

  • 16 August 2022

    1.1 MINS

    Victorian MP Fiona Patten is pushing a new bill that aims to take away the rights of publicly funded hospitals with religious affiliations to refuse to perform abortions and euthanasia. The state’s current laws allow women to access an abortion up to 24 weeks into [...]

  • 15 August 2022

    2.5 MINS

    Do you think you can find a Coles staff member to scan your groceries after 8pm? If only they did acknowledgement of customer as well as they do Acknowledgement of Country! It was revealed last week that Coles supermarkets now print an Acknowledgment of Country [...]

  • 15 August 2022

    9.9 MINS

    I was shocked to read a recent survey that found less than half of Australians believe Jesus was a real person. Whatever else you may think of him, to be uncertain of Jesus’ very existence is absurd: that Jesus was a real person can be [...]

  • 15 August 2022

    5.3 MINS

    How are you doing in God’s refining process? According to Scripture, God both tests and refines His people, and images of refining fires, crucibles for metals, purifying fires, the smelting process, and the like are often used. While testing and purifying are somewhat distinct but [...]

  • 12 August 2022

    4.8 MINS

    Yes, as Christians, we should share our values and beliefs with others -- boldly and unapologetically. It may be uncomfortable, but it is our prophetic duty and also our democratic right to speak up. I hear Christians all the time saying that we cannot and [...]

  • 12 August 2022

    2.8 MINS

    Editor's Note: Writing in News Weekly, former President of the National Civic Council Peter Westmore points out the erroneous claims made by the Minister for the Environment which will infect national policy, further eroding our agricultural and fishing industries. ___ Unveiling the “State of the [...]