Israel Folau and the Fight for Freedom
Back in 2017 I flew down to Tasmania to interview the Roman Catholic Archbishop of Hobart, Julian Porteous. The Archbishop had been brought before the Anti-Discrimination Board simply for producing a booklet outlining the traditional Christian understanding of marriage.
But the real reason I went was because—even before a decision on same-sex marriage had been reached—I could see that what was ultimately at stake was the issue of religious freedom. And now, only a couple of years later, that ‘threat’ has become a reality.
Israel Folau is now being sued by the gay political activist — and serial litigant — Gary Burns for ‘homosexual vilification’. This is despite the fact that Folau has been given an official apology by Rugby Australia. In case you’ve been living under a rock, or maybe just coming out of a medically-induced coma, this is what Folau had posted:
Interestingly, there have been no liars, fornicators, drunkards, adulterers, thieves, atheists or idolaters who have decided to take a similar course of action. Which is all the more significant when one considers that there are proportionally far more people that fit into one of these seven categories then there are who identify as being LGBTIQ+. In fact, looking again at the list, it includes absolutely everyone!
But there’s a connection between what Burns is doing to Folau now and what happened to Archbishop Porteous down in Hobart. And that is, the process is the punishment. Because the goal is not that the complainant will win, but it’s that you will go broke merely trying to defend yourself against them. Just ask Bernard Gaynor, who has had a staggering thirty-six complaints made against him by Burns and has even had to sell his house to finance his legal costs.
You see, as far as the law is concerned, Mr. Burns doesn’t really have a case. The legislation is already there giving people the freedom to form a different point of view on the basis of religious teaching. As Mark Latham tweeted:
NSW Anti-Discrimination Board decision to persecute Israel Folau is chilling for all religious preachers/freedoms.
Section 49ZT of the Act has an exemption from ‘Homosexual vilification’ action for ‘religious instruction’, discussion, debate and ‘expositions of any act or matter’— Real Mark Latham (@RealMarkLatham) December 13, 2019
What Latham is pointing out here is absolutely spot on. And the specific terminology that he is using is also just as important. Because the strategy of suing people into silence is part of a larger legal approach called the ‘chilling effect’. It’s what Wikipedia defines as “…the inhibition or discouragement of the legitimate exercise of natural and legal rights by the threat of legal sanction.”
Do you think any other denominational leader in Tasmania has produced a booklet on marriage since what happened to Porteous? Or has any other sporting celebrity been brave enough to post anything on social media similar to Israel Folau? That’s what the chilling effect achieves! And it is incredibly effective…
Maybe we should all change our Facebook profiles to Israel’s original post? Not to be offensive, but to prevent ourselves from being frozen out of the current situation. For make no mistake, this is not the end of the fight but rather, only the beginning. And it’s only a matter of time before the political activists catch up with you or me.
___
Photo: David Molloy, Wikimedia Commons.
Recent Articles:
16 June 2026
4.5 MINS
Comedian Dave Hughes has unleashed on the Albanese Government, arguing there was no mandate for the recent tax changes and regretting voting for Labor at the last election.
16 June 2026
2.7 MINS
The South Australian Parliament is set to debate a private members bill that — if passed — will allow a biological man who identifies as a woman to record himself as the “mother” on the child’s birth certificate. It has already passed the Upper House with support from the Greens and Labor.
16 June 2026
3.9 MINS
Recall Andrew Thorburn. He lost his job not because he did anything wrong, but because a new worldview has quietly captured Australia's public square. The Australian Christian Freedom Index shows just how far that capture has gone.
16 June 2026
6.3 MINS
It is not government’s role to adjudicate theological debates. Over a controversy over whether the label 'Christian' should be applied to the Mormon Church, the Pentagon passed this test with flying colours.
15 June 2026
2.8 MINS
Living under a $1 million CCP bounty, exiled Hong Konger Frances Hui has been named this year's recipient of the Victims of Communism Dissident Human Rights Award for her continued fight against the regime.
15 June 2026
5.1 MINS
Parents of Down syndrome children have spoken out, sharing the joy of raising their children, after internet influencer Jesse Ridgway posted explaining why he and his wife chose to abort their baby after a genetic test came back positive for Trisomy 21.
15 June 2026
3.4 MINS
Pro-life Health Professionals Australia (PHPA) has issued two statements critiquing claims made by two medical institutions opposing moves to see late-term abortion restricted in South Australia. PHPA will support a public pro-life rally outside Parliament House, Adelaide, on 17 June.
