Is This Child Abuse?
The polarisation of medicine and medical defence organisations.
The mutually exclusive “affirming” pathways for children wishing to change sex represent a clear ethical divide in which it is essential for medicine, not activists and not governments, to be decisive and authoritative. There is no neutral.
It is inevitable that at some point there will be consumer legal action for either affirming OR failing to affirm.
Who will decide? Will it be doctors, psychologists or the lawmakers? If doctors, then will it be the psychiatrists or paediatricians who tend to have opposing views? Associations of paediatricians hold very definite opposing views.
Which side of the polarity regarding child abuse will Medical Defence Organisations defend? If they defend surgeons who do transgender mastectomy for a 25-year-old on the grounds that fully informed consent was given, will they also defend surgeons who have done the same procedure for a 13-year-old who decides to sue when an adult?
Further, will MDOs defend the surgeon who refuses to do a mastectomy for a 13-year-old?
And how will MDOs decide? Will different MDOs have different approaches to these matters because their boards have been taken over by people with set ideologies?
Will MDOs simply side with what is legal — if governments declare that affirmation of birth sex or reversal counselling is child abuse and punishable by law?
For the sake of our MDO insurance premiums we need decisions now, rather than a decade from now. It is to be hoped that MDOs will continue their honourable, professional status and be much more than just another insurance company.
This is a clear ethical divide in which it is essential for medicine, not activists and not governments, to be decisive and authoritative. There is no neutral.
A note regarding the affirmation of feelings, unsupported by evidence:
“Yes, you must affirm the feelings — progress is not possible unless you do.”
“The evidence doesn’t have to support the feeling — it doesn’t have to be totally true.”
Déjà vu?
Consider “recovered memories syndrome”. After attending a seminar in 1995 on Memories of Abuse, I wrote the following:
If we have not ultimately questioned historical accuracy by using intervention strategies at some point, and 20 people are imprisoned as a result of subsequent criminal charges, and it is then found that the memories were not factual, then — despite the existence of disclaimers and contracts — we may be accused of having failed in this wider responsibility. This is equally true even if only one person is unjustly imprisoned, and it is also true even if only one person is unjustly accused.
Regarding those suffering gender dysphoria: if we have not even queried whether there are possible contributing factors or stressors in children wishing to change their sex — such querying itself labelled as abuse by those who insist on affirming the wish — then we have failed our ethical and professional responsibilities as doctors, and our duty as community leaders and parents.
We have failed the child and we have failed the community. We have failed medicine.
___
Originally published at Choose Life Australia.
Photo by Sandy Millar on Unsplash.
Recent Articles:
3 August 2026
7.9 MINS
Ceuta, Spain's enclave on Morocco's coast, faces unprecedented chaos as tens of thousands breach borders in what leaders are calling an invasion. The crisis exposes the catastrophic consequences of open-border policies across Europe.
3 August 2026
5.7 MINS
To understand Neo-Marxism, we first need to understand the realities of Marxism. Not the politically cleaned up propaganda version, but the brutal realities of the lives, and deaths, of those who lived and died under it.
3 August 2026
5.2 MINS
An unholy alliance between secular progressives and Islamists is reshaping the West. But the two movements operate from fundamentally different moral universes — and one is far better equipped to win the long game.
3 August 2026
2.8 MINS
Joel Phillips didn't hand his son a screen — he handed him an opportunity. Now seven-year-old Miles' catchy tune "Eastern Rosellas" has gone viral, proving imagination and dad-time are a powerful combination.
31 July 2026
3.3 MINS
On Monday Senator Rand Paul released over 1,000 pages of Fauci’s musings, written in his journal during the COVID era — which shockingly reveal that what Fauci demanded the public to believe was very different to what he knew to be the truth.
31 July 2026
12.3 MINS
Christopher Nolan's adaptation of "The Odyssey" deploys progressive messaging beneath a veneer of cinematic spectacle, using identity politics to create a revisionist betrayal of Homer's original epic. Here's a reveal of this ideology so it doesn't ensnare you.
31 July 2026
5.8 MINS
The Trump administration has cut $67 million of taxpayer funding for controversial “radical leftist sex ed” programs in favour of solid curriculum that emphasises abstinence and marriage.
