
Disciplining Your Children — A Dad’s Cry for Help
Some time ago, I was busy minding my own business in my office, when I heard my wife talking in the next office to a stranger. I opened my door to shake hands with Bill, who was inspecting our fire services in our office on behalf of the landlord.
Bill, realising he was in the offices of Dads4Kids, started to ply me with questions about parenting.
He asked, “How should I handle disciplining my twelve year old daughter?”
I answered with a question of my own: “What do you mean?’”
“Well, it is like this,” he countered, “I have two beautiful daughters — one is nearly 17 years old, and the other is 12 years old. I don’t understand! Our elder daughter gave us no trouble; she is mature, careful, disciplined and well-mannered, but the 12-year-old is a real handful.”
I smiled knowingly and said, “All children are different, and you just have to do your best to make the adjustments you have to make as a father for each child. Treat each of your children the same, but allow for their differences, and as you accommodate their different needs and character traits, as best you are able, you will be successful.”
His questions continued: “What about the fact that my wife is much more strict a disciplinarian than I am? I think she is too harsh and she thinks I am too weak. What should I do?”
“For starters,” I retorted, “the worst thing you can do is give your children no discipline. If you don’t teach your children consequences, you are not teaching them to live in the real world.”
Discipline is essential for success, and true discipline is a product that comes from love.
What I said next came as a bit of a surprise for Bill: “The place of agreement is the place of power.” I repeated it again, hoping it would sink in. “The worst thing you can do is disagree with your wife about discipline, especially in front of your child. You MUST come into agreement.
“If she is too strict and you are too easy, probably halfway would be exactly right.”
“Children are born barristers and they will exploit your differences every time: ‘Mum said this, Dad said that.’ In the art of warfare, it’s called ‘divide and conquer.’
“You cannot afford to disagree. You will have to come to a compromise and form a united front on the issue of discipline, especially if your children are very headstrong.”
I gave him an example of the art of firm but loving compromise from the experiences of an army brigadier I knew: “His youngest daughter was incredibly messy. He and his wife tried hard to get her to be tidy, but it seemed impossible, so much so that they thought they might lose her affection because of the constant harping on her untidiness throughout the house as well as in her room.
“Her parents got together and agreed that she could be messy inside her bedroom, but outside, the rules of the home applied. The compromise worked, the house stayed tidy and they kept their daughter’s affection, which in the end, is the thing that matters.”
I also told Bill how important he is to his daughter. “When we first started Dads4Kids in 2002, I thought that it was the father/son relationship that was the main responsibility for a father, but all my years of reading and research have shown me that the father/daughter relationship is just as vital and important, perhaps more so.”
“For example, this interesting piece of research may surprise you: girls growing up without their biological father in the home menstruate 9 months earlier than those who have their father present in the home.”
Bill looked shocked, “I know what you are talking about,” he said. “All my daughter’s friends from broken homes have started their periods, but she hasn’t yet.”
“Don’t worry,” I said, “This is something to be glad about. Your daughter is secure. She feels the love between you and your wife and towards her. That love is providing security for her body clock.
“You and your wife should be encouraged for the great job you are doing raising your daughters. You are in the top 10% of dads. Most dads can’t articulate the questions you are asking.”
So, I asked Bill if I could share about our meeting and the questions he had about being a Dad with the Dads4Kids weekly newsletter, because every man needs help with these sort of questions.
Aren’t you glad he said yes?
Lovework
If you are reading this newsletter on a weekly basis, you are very committed. Like the father above, you are in the top 10% of dads. I would like to congratulate you! Keep reading and keep asking those sorts of questions, because it will do your children the world of good.
Yours for more good questions,
Warwick Marsh
PS: Tomorrow (Sunday) 14 February is Valentine’s Day. If you haven’t got something for your wife, better get it very quickly. If she says she does not care, she is lying. Your wife needs your special attention today and every day, but particularly tomorrow.
Read last week’s Valentine’s Day article. Don’t miss the opportunity to give your wife some attention!
[Photo by Senjuti Kundu on Unsplash]Recent Articles:
24 July 2026
5.9 MINS
Most Australians know Jacinta Price. Fewer know her husband, Colin Lillie — a man who went from falling out with God to crediting him with saving his life. In an interview with The Daily Declaration, Lillie opens up about his journey through addiction and recovery, and why he’s speaking out now on cancel culture, truth, and what real forgiveness looks like.
22 July 2026
2.7 MINS
We need to talk about the situation in Tasmania and how we desperately need prayer. The Greens have introduced a “Conversion Practices Prohibition Bill” into the Tasmanian Parliament that will have devastating ramifications for Christians, parents, and all those who, of their own volition, want to break with the current cultural state-sanctioned morality.
21 July 2026
8.2 MINS
We don't talk about social atomisation, do we? Most of us would be hard pressed to define it. Yet it is reshaping our society in ways we barely acknowledge — fragmenting our communities, eroding our connections, and leaving us isolated in the midst of billions.
20 July 2026
3 MINS
It’s been said women have relationships face to face while men have relationships shoulder to shoulder. As a husband, father of five daughters, and CEO whose work is encouraging men to be the best they can be, I couldn’t agree more.
17 July 2026
3.8 MINS
Jillian Spencer, a Queensland psychiatrist suspended for questioning childhood gender treatments, has been cleared by AHPRA, as her hospital prepares to release its own statement.
15 July 2026
4.2 MINS
Multi-platinum rock band Skillet has achieved major mainstream success while openly maintaining a committed Christian faith, resisting industry pressure to downplay their evangelical beliefs. Lead singer John Cooper, known for his vocal faith, has testified to the power of the gospel, which the band brings to a global audience through their music.
15 July 2026
4.6 MINS
Despite the medical pendulum swinging against it, a mainline American denomination has thrown its full support behind the crumbling facade of transgender medicine. The Presbyterian Church (USA) voted overwhelmingly to declare support for access 'transgender medical procedures'.





